Posts Tagged ‘press’
Wednesday, April 21st, 2010
The next day after the discussion about the advantages of a free and open press, we considered the problems and abuses of the press by reading the NorthStar selections carefully.
All of these discussions gave the students a little taste of university courses on Media Studies. We made a list of the kinds of things people criticize in the press:
- news companies want to make profits and they like sensational stories (like the NorthStar story about coverage of the bombing suspect)
- sometimes they print things without being sure of the evidence
- they are too intrusive in people’s private lives, particularly politicians (Gennifer Flowers in the NorthStar story)
- they give too much time to stars and athletes
- they only talk about what’s good for their own country
What do yours students think of the press? Do these issues come up in class? How do you usually structure the discussions and activities?
We also discussed libel laws in different countries. In the U.S., if you are considered a “public figure” a libel verdict is very hard to prove since it is assumed that you put yourself forward and have to take the consequences of the “free market of ideas.” In other countries, the question of libel is more narrowly defined.
Tags: bias, discussion, efl, esl, esol, libel, media studies, northstar, press, teaching, tefl, tesl, tesol, tips
Posted in L/S 4, Unit 1, Listening and Speaking, Listening/Speaking 4, R/W 4, Unit 1, Reading and Writing, Reading/Writing 4 | No Comments »
Monday, April 19th, 2010
In a subsequent class we listened to Bill Moyers Journal on subject of the Alternative Press. He interviewed the journalists from “Democracy Now” and salon.com.
This was a very challenging listening for the students BUT I played only the first 7 minutes of the interview. Then I allowed them to read the interactive transcript provided by the program. We listened again and discussed the answers to my comprehension questions in groups.
Here are the exercises I used.
The students really got into the discussion.
One student said he thought journalists were killed in some countries (including his own) because they told lies. Another student asked him why anyone would kill reporters because they told lies. It seemed more likely that they were telling a truth that powerful people didn’t want to hear.
Lots of silence after that exchange.
Some students defended censorship on the internet “because young people can be influenced to do bad things.” The idea of being able to “make up your own mind” and having access to information was discussed –“the right to know.” In a dictatorship, it doesn’t matter whether the average citizen is well-informed. In fact, it’s better for government control if they are not.
These discussions have been great for getting students to really engage with the language and use new words and expressions. What lessons have you created that got students’ interest?
Tags: authentic listening, Bill Moyers, censorship, debate, discussion, efl, esl, esol, freedom, ideas, press, teaching, tefl, tesl, tesol, tips, video
Posted in L/S 4, Unit 1, Listening and Speaking, Listening/Speaking 4, R/W 4, Unit 1, Reading and Writing, Reading/Writing 4 | No Comments »
Friday, April 16th, 2010
After our initial discussion about freedom of the press, we broke up into small groups and discussed where we get our information about the wider world:
__ TV
__ radio
__ newspapers
__ the internet
The class had some lively contributions about all of this. Most of the young people from countries with a free press said they preferred the internet because they thought it was easier to find what interests them.
However, students from some countries said less than 5% of households in their country had internet access. For them, the “information overload” was non-existent. We discussed how the internet allows for more varied sources of information but also some dangers, such as unfiltered information from biased sources.
What about your students? Do you have a similar breakdown among your students? How have you handled this?
Some students asked about Fox News and how biased that network was against the President in the recent health care debate. We discussed whether a “free press” means that every news broadcast has to be objective.
Is total objectivity possible? Many said yes. We discussed the fact that if some channels are pro-conservative, others are pro-liberal and if we know that, we can get some balance. Some students were shocked that the country allowed people to make fun of the President.
Have you ever looked at bias in US news media? How have you structured those lessons?
Tags: bias, efl, esl, esol, freedom, media, news, northstar, press, teaching, tefl, tesl, tesol
Posted in L/S 4, Unit 1, Listening and Speaking, Listening/Speaking 4, R/W 4, Unit 1, Reading and Writing, Reading/Writing 4 | No Comments »
Wednesday, April 14th, 2010
Hi Everyone!
Last week we worked on Unit 1 on the Press. One of the reading selections in the NorthStar Reading/Writing book deals with the intrusive nature of the press and the other discusses a miscarriage of justice that occurred when press coverage vilified someone who was merely a “suspect” in a crime.
These are definitely important issues to consider but to address the needs of my students, many of whom come from countries where there is no free press; we decided to start back at the beginning: why is a free press essential in a democratic system?
We began with a series of exercises on the First amendment.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Journalism is the only profession specifically protected by the Constitution. There must be a reason. First we worked on the meaning of the first amendment (in a general way).
The idea of an “established” religion was hard for them to understand but I cited the example of Great Britain, where the official religion is the Church of England and the king or queen is the titular head of the Church and the State. At a certain point in history, even if you were not a member of the Church of England, your taxes still went to support this Church. This is what the founding fathers wanted to avoid.
We then discussed why freedom of speech naturally leads to freedom to PUBLISH and CIRCULATE ideas. Why is this right necessary? My students came up with:
- everyone’s ideas have to be heard in a democracy
- the press can tell about government corruption or mistakes
Tags: constituion, efl, esl, esol, freedom, media, northstar, press, teaching, tefl, tesl, tesol
Posted in R/W 4, Unit 1, Reading and Writing, Reading/Writing 4 | 1 Comment »
